Turn Holiday Returns Into Gift-Giving Opportunities

Every January, ecommerce stores brace for the return wave. 30% of all online purchases are returned, with that number spiking after the holidays. But what if you could turn this perceived negative into a positive customer experience?

The key is shifting your mindset: every return is an opportunity to create a new loyal customer—whether that's the original gift-giver who'll shop with you again, or the gift recipient who's now discovering your brand.

Why Holiday Returns Are Actually Opportunities

Consider what's happening when someone returns a gift:

🎁
New customer touchpoint: The gift recipient is interacting with your brand for the first time
💰
Exchange opportunity: They already have store credit or are browsing for an exchange
📧
Email capture: Returns require contact information you might not otherwise have
❤️
Loyalty opportunity: A smooth return experience creates positive brand associations

Strategy 1: Incentivize Exchanges Over Refunds

The goal is to keep the revenue in your ecosystem. Offer compelling reasons to exchange rather than refund:

Bonus store credit: "Exchange and get an extra 10% credit"
Free shipping on exchanges: Remove friction from the exchange process
Exclusive access: "Exchangers get early access to new arrivals"
Gift with exchange: Small bonus item for choosing exchange over refund

Example Messaging

"We're sorry this gift wasn't quite right! Exchange for something you'll love and we'll add a $10 bonus to your order. Or, if you prefer a refund, we understand—we'll process it within 24 hours."

Strategy 2: Create a Gift Recipient Welcome Flow

When a gift recipient initiates a return, they're often a brand-new customer. Welcome them properly:

Return Confirmation Email

Thank them for being part of your community (even via a gift)
Explain the return timeline clearly
Include personalized product recommendations
Offer a first-time customer discount on their next purchase

Post-Return Nurture Sequence

Email 1 (Day 3): "Find something you'll love" with curated picks
Email 2 (Day 7): Share your brand story and values
Email 3 (Day 14): Exclusive offer to convert them to a buyer

Strategy 3: Make Returns Frictionless

A painful return experience poisons the relationship. Make it easy:

Pre-paid return labels: Include in gift orders or make instantly printable
Extended holiday windows: 60-90 day returns for holiday purchases
Self-service portal: No customer service wait times required
Drop-off options: Partner with return aggregators for easy drop-off

💡 Pro Tip

For gift returns, don't require the original receipt. The gift-giver shouldn't need to be involved, and recipients often don't have order details.

Strategy 4: Capture Feedback for Future Gifting

Returns provide valuable data about your gift products:

Why was this gift returned? (Size, style, already owned, etc.)
What would have been a better choice?
How can product descriptions better help gift-givers?

Use this feedback to improve your gift guides and product recommendations.

Strategy 5: The "Keep the Gift" Option

For low-value items where return shipping costs exceed product value, consider a "keep the gift" policy:

Keep It Policy Benefits

✓ Eliminates return shipping costs
✓ Creates massive positive sentiment
✓ Item may still be used or regifted
✓ Generates social media buzz

Messaging: "We're processing your full refund. Please keep or donate the item—no need to ship it back!"

Strategy 6: Convert the Original Gift-Giver

Don't forget about the person who originally purchased the gift. When a gift is returned:

Send a gentle notification (if they opted in)
Offer a discount on their next gift purchase
Suggest gift cards for future occasions
Provide better gift selection guidance for next time

Metrics to Track

Measure how well you're converting returns into opportunities:

Exchange rate: % of returns that become exchanges
Return-to-customer conversion: % of returners who make a future purchase
Return NPS: Customer satisfaction with return process
Bonus credit utilization: % who use exchange incentives

Prepare Before the Rush

Set up these systems before the holiday season ends:

Create gift recipient email flows
Set up exchange incentive codes
Train customer service on gift return handling
Update return policy for holiday purchases
Build return feedback surveys

The January return rush is coming whether you're ready or not. With the right strategies, you can turn it from a cost center into a customer acquisition channel.

Create Gift Experiences Worth Keeping

WithGifted helps create personalized gift experiences that recipients love—reducing returns before they happen.

Install WithGifted Free →